Medical experts reject claims that reversing the “feminisation” of general practice will solve the UK’s acute GP workforce crisis.
General practice faces a deepening workforce crisis that won’t be solved by recruiting more male doctors, medical experts have warned. The BMJ has challenged suggestions that the growing proportion of female GPs is behind staffing shortages across the NHS.
The UK has almost 16% fewer fully qualified GPs per population than other high-income countries, according to government data. This stark shortfall has left practices struggling to meet patient demand despite successive promises to expand GP numbers.
The Numbers Behind the Crisis
England had 5% fewer fully trained whole-time equivalent GPs in November 2021 than in 2015. This decline came despite government commitments to boost GP recruitment and training places.
Data from the General Medical Council shows female doctors registered to practise in the UK are growing at a faster rate than males. But medical workforce experts argue this trend reflects broader changes in medical education rather than the cause of staffing problems.
The proportion of UK medical graduates choosing general practice training isn’t increasing. Many training places are now filled by international medical graduates rather than homegrown talent.
Why Gender Isn’t the Problem
Women comprise three-quarters of the NHS workforce overall. Yet they face higher burnout rates and remain underrepresented in senior roles despite their growing numbers in medical training.
General practice is described as the bedrock of the NHS but faces systemic challenges that go far beyond workforce composition. Successive governments have responded with structural changes and additional roles rather than addressing core recruitment and retention issues.
The government plans a refreshed NHS workforce plan focused on shifting care to community settings. This follows Lord Darzi’s report highlighting systemic NHS issues including historic underinvestment in primary care.
What Needs to Change
Healthcare unions including the Royal College of Nursing warn the crisis demands urgent funding for fair pay and terms. Without this, they predict continued instability in GP recruitment and retention.
Medical experts call for radical action on training expansion and better working conditions. Simply changing the gender balance won’t address the fundamental pressures driving doctors away from general practice.
Source: @bmj_latest
Key Takeaways
- UK has 16% fewer GPs per population than other wealthy nations despite government expansion promises
- Female doctors are growing faster than males but experts say gender composition isn’t causing the workforce crisis
- Training places increasingly filled by international graduates as UK medical students choose other specialties
What This Means for Kent Residents
Kent residents continue facing GP access challenges as local practices struggle with the same national recruitment crisis affecting surgeries across England. NHS Kent and Medway Integrated Care Board reports ongoing primary care pressures including long waits for routine appointments. For urgent health needs, residents should call NHS 111 or check with their local Primary Care Network for extended access hubs that may offer evening and weekend appointments during these workforce strains.
Test Your Knowledge
5 questions


Arsenal
Manchester City
Manchester United
Liverpool
Aston Villa
Brentford
Brighton
Bournemouth
Chelsea
Fulham
Everton
Sunderland
Newcastle
Crystal Palace
Leeds
Nottingham Forest
West Ham
Tottenham
Burnley
Wolves
Coventry
Ipswich
Millwall
Southampton
Middlesbrough
Hull City
Wrexham
Derby
Norwich
Birmingham
Swansea
Bristol City
Sheffield Utd
Preston
QPR
Watford
Stoke City
Portsmouth
Charlton
Blackburn
West Brom
Oxford United
Leicester
Sheffield Wednesday
Lincoln
Cardiff
Stockport County
Bradford
Bolton
Stevenage
Luton
Plymouth
Huddersfield
Mansfield Town
Wycombe
Reading
Blackpool
Doncaster
Barnsley
Wigan
Burton Albion
Peterborough
AFC Wimbledon
Leyton Orient
Exeter City
Port Vale
Rotherham
Northampton
Bromley
Milton Keynes Dons
Cambridge United
Salford City
Notts County
Chesterfield
Grimsby
Barnet
Swindon Town
Oldham
Crewe
Colchester
Walsall
Bristol Rovers
Fleetwood Town
Accrington ST
Gillingham
Cheltenham
Shrewsbury
Newport County
Tranmere
Crawley Town
Harrogate Town
Barrow
York
Rochdale
Carlisle
Boreham Wood
Scunthorpe
Southend
Forest Green
FC Halifax Town
Hartlepool
Woking
Tamworth
Boston United
Altrincham
Solihull Moors
Wealdstone
Yeovil Town
Eastleigh
Gateshead
Sutton Utd
Aldershot Town
Brackley Town
Morecambe
Braintree
Truro City
AFC Fylde
South Shields
Kidderminster Harriers
Macclesfield
Buxton
Scarborough Athletic
Chester
Merthyr Town
Darlington 1883
Spennymoor Town
AFC Telford United
Marine
Radcliffe
Southport
Chorley
Worksop Town
Oxford City
Bedford Town
King's Lynn Town
Hereford
Curzon Ashton
Alfreton Town
Peterborough Sports
Leamington
Worthing
AFC Hornchurch
Torquay
Dorking Wanderers
Hemel Hempstead Town
Weston-super-Mare
Maidenhead
Maidstone Utd
Ebbsfleet United
Chelmsford City
Chesham United
AFC Totton
Dagenham & Redbridge
Tonbridge Angels
Horsham
Slough Town
Salisbury
Hampton & Richmond
Farnborough
Dover
Bath City
Chippenham Town
Enfield Town
Eastbourne Borough
